…or suburbs
Well, hello loyal readers and fans! I know, it’s been YEARS since I’ve eaten a bagel and it has been ROUGH.
Just kidding: I’ve had a shit load of bagels since my last post, I’ve just been too lazy to write about them.
Well, perhaps more importantly, I think most of the bagels I DID consume in my hiatus were from the same 1-2 places that I’ve already reviewed. So, not much new to report.
OK moving on.
So I’ve had to go to the suburbs more recently for doctor appointments and, when I say suburbs, I mean where the reform Jews live. You know, the North Shore. A place that I don’t really fit into, but still somehow resonates with me? Like I fully identify as a Jew but since I didn’t grow up surrounded by Jews, I feel a bit like an outsider when I’m there. Luckily bagels are the great equalizer.
I’m actually going to review two different establishments in this post. Yes, this is a two-fer (what a treat!)
First up is Max’s Deli
This is an interesting place because it’s owned by an Italian Jew. Yes, an Italian Jew. IMO Jews and Italians are basically the same, but Italians have the better food* in general and Jews are funnier. (SORRY) (But we know they love working together because they had a lot of synergy in the Mafia!)
Anyways, this place is basically a humongous take-out deli/bakery and restaurant in one. Service is a bit weird: I’d categorize it as slightly abrasive but then you feel bad because it seems like the workers are stressed out. The owner is…well…an interesting character. I sense that the stress comes from the top, let’s put it that way.
Now onto the food: the bagels are decent. I would say they’re better than many of the city bagels I’ve had but, at the time, I wouldn’t place them at Once Upon a Bagel level.
Next up is Max and Benny’s
I should preface this review with saying I’ve been here before with my grandparents, but didn’t have the bagels or the deli/bakery.
This is another huge half-bakery-half-restaurant establishment. Now, being that I am of 40%+ English ancestry, I do appreciate a line. We need structure and order in our lives, especially when it comes to ordering food. The last thing I want to do when I see bagels AND AM HUNGRY is evil eye everyone around me because I’m not sure who will respect the lack of order and who won’t.
So this place was basically like being in Israel. No rules. No clear responsibilites. I felt like I had just stepped into the schawarma place in Old Jerusalem where I waited in line for FORTY FIVE MINUTES to order when there were like 2 people ahead of me when I first walked in.
Yes, the old people at Max and Benny’s really gave 0 shits about the fact that I was there before them and clearly didn’t know which way was up. Is this not America? Give me bagels or give me death, come on people. What made matters worse is that one I finally got helped, I didn’t only get helped by one person, it was like 3+ people who were all somehow “taking care of me” but none of them knew who was working on my order so by the end my head was spinning. Somehow I felt like I was to blame for the confusion, and I was not a happy camper at the end of that experience.
HOWEVER.
The bagels are my new favorite. First off, they are JEWMONGOUS. I mean, these bagels are BIG. And when you’re living through a recession, you appreciate getting your money’s worth. Secondly, they have the right texture combo: slightly crispy outside met with the perfect fluff inside. And forget about the cream cheese: I don’t even know how to describe it, but it is just perfect. PERFECT COMBINATION, THEY WIN.
They also have a superb chocolate chip mandel bread (which I realized is basically like biscotti but better…sorry again, Italian readers); a s’mores bar that is a ridiculous amount of sugar and love condensed into one oversized treat; good challah bread, and even enjoyed the kreplach!
SO yes I dropped $50+ at this place and, despite my wild west experience actually getting my food from the counter, I can’t wait to get back. Now that I know the drill, all the krechers better watch out because I am NOT waiting around with my thumb up my ass like last time. No butts no cuts no coconuts today.
*except bagels and kugel